Liga MX

End of an era? ‘Chicharito’s’ failure at Chivas ends with a missed penalty

His second stint at Chivas has also been marked by controversy: a strident personality off the field.

His second stint at Chivas has also been marked by controversy: a strident personality off the field.
Luis Fernando Toris
Ciudad de México Update:

Javier “Chicharito” Hernández has long embraced a personal philosophy: imagine great things, no matter how hard they are to achieve. His homecoming to Chivas — the club where he grew up and launched his career — was meant to reignite the team’s glory days.

But one missed penalty against Cruz Azul changed the narrative. What could have been a triumphant chapter turned into a painful metaphor for his second stint with the club.

End of an era? ‘Chicharito’s’ failure at Chivas ends with a missed penalty
Javier Chicharito Hernandez of Guadalajara during the quarter-final second match between Cruz Azul and Guadalajara as part of the Liga BBVA MX, Torneo Apertura 2025 at Olimpico Universitario Stadium, on November 30, 2025 in Mexico City, Mexico.Jose Luis Melgarejo

The weight of the decisive spotkick

When it looked like Luis Romo would step up to take the crucial penalty, Chicharito grabbed the ball instead. All eyes at Estadio Olímpico Universitario locked on him. The pressure was immense, and his shot sailed high over the crossbar. The miss didn’t just cost Chivas the chance to advance — it symbolized the struggles of his return.

Leadership in the locker room

Beyond goals, many point to Hernández’s value in the locker room. His presence, experience, and ability to pass down Chivas’ identity to younger players have been praised. Still, critics argue that strikers are ultimately judged by their scoring record — and that’s where his impact has fallen short in this second chapter.

End of an era? ‘Chicharito’s’ failure at Chivas ends with a missed penalty
Javier -Chicharito- Hernandez of Guadalajara during the 16th round match between Pachuca and Guadalajara as part of the Liga BBVA MX, Torneo Apertura 2025 at Hidalgo Stadium, on November 02, 2025 in Pachuca, Hidalgo, Mexico.Jose Luis Melgarejo

Then vs. now

Chicharito’s time with Chivas can be split into two eras:

  1. The rising star who dazzled before heading to Europe, scoring 29 goals before joining Manchester United.
  2. The veteran returnee who, despite an illustrious international career, has managed just four goals since coming back.


The contrast between past brilliance and present struggles is stark.

Controversies and injuries

Related stories

His comeback has also been clouded by off-field controversiesoutspoken comments, social media posts, and a larger-than-life personality that often drew headlines. On the field, recurring injuries have limited his rhythm and kept him from resembling the electrifying forward fans once adored.

Dive into live coverage, expert insights, breaking news, exclusive videos, and more – plus, stay updated on the latest in current affairs and entertainment. Download now for all-access coverage, right at your fingertips – anytime, anywhere.

Tagged in:
Comments
Rules

Complete your personal details to comment

We recommend these for you in Soccer